Get to Know Us: Joel McKinnon Farmers Insurance Agency – Local Roots, Multi-State Reach 🌟
At the Joel McKinnon Farmers Insurance Agency, we’re more than just your local insurance team — we’re a dedicated partner committed to protecting what matters most to you, wherever life takes you. Proudly rooted in Dover, Ohio, we’ve been serving families, homeowners, and businesses in our hometown and surrounding communities for over two decades.
🧭 Expanding Protection Beyond Ohio

While we love being a hometown agent for our neighbors in Dover, New Philadelphia, Strasburg, and throughout Tuscarawas County, we’re also proud to be licensed to serve clients across:
- Pennsylvania
- Tennessee
- Michigan
Whether you’re buying your dream home in Pittsburgh, setting up a new life in Nashville, or insuring your family car in Grand Rapids — we can help. Learn more about our home insurance, auto insurance, and commercial insurance offerings.
🏕️ Need Weekend or Vacation Property Coverage?
We also understand that many of our clients escape the everyday grind to unwind in a cabin in the woods or a condo on the beach. That’s why we proudly represent Foremost Insurance in:
- West Virginia
- North Carolina
Foremost offers outstanding coverage for second homes, mobile homes, vacation rentals, and more — and we can help make sure you’re protected in those out-of-state getaways, even if your primary residence isn’t in Ohio. Check out our vacation property insurance page for details.
🛡️ Why Farmers?
We are honored to represent Farmers Insurance, one of the most trusted and recognized names in the industry. Backed by the strength of Farmers and our dedication to customer service, our agency delivers both personalized local attention and the national power of a premier insurance carrier.
From home, auto, and life insurance to specialty coverages and small business insurance, our team is here to find the right policy for your needs and your budget — no matter where you live, or where your properties are located.
🧭 We’re Licensed to Help, Even If You’re Not in Ohio
One of the biggest misconceptions we hear is: “I didn’t know you could help me if I don’t live in Ohio.” The truth is — we can. Even if your primary home and auto aren’t based in Ohio, we can still assist you in PA, TN, MI, WV, and NC.
So whether you’re a longtime Ohio resident with a vacation property in the mountains, or a new client in another state who loves working with a responsive, high-quality agency — we’re here for you.
📞 Call us at (330) 339-3431
🌐 Visit joelmckinnon.com
Or simply stop in and say hello if you’re in the neighborhood.
At the Joel McKinnon Farmers Insurance Agency, we’re proud to be local — and ready to serve you wherever you go.







